Heritage's video game sale closes this weekend, with a first-print Mario at $75,000 and a sealed first-print Zelda

Heritage Auctions' Video Games Signature Auction ends on November 20 and 21 in Dallas. Two of the most important early Nintendo games are at the top of it, and bids on both had passed five figures before the live session.
The lots to watch
A first-production Super Mario Bros., complete in box, graded PSA 9.0. This is the matte-sticker version tied to Nintendo's New York test launch of the NES in October 1985. Bidding had reached $75,000 before the November 20 session, CollectiblesNews reported on November 17. Heritage calls it the highest-graded PSA copy of the variant it has brought to auction, tied with three others at the top of PSA's August 2026 census for complete copies. Its grades are 8.5 for the box, 9.2 for the cartridge and 9.0 for the manual. Heritage says no sealed first-production copy is known.
A sealed 1987 The Legend of Zelda graded CGC 8.0 A (lot 28018). This is the "TM" first print, the earliest North American retail release. Bids had passed $50,000 by November 5, per CGC, which says sealed copies of these early prints left on the market are in the single digits.
Also in the sale, per Heritage via CollectiblesNews and CGC:
- an unopened 1996 Japanese launch edition of Super Mario 64. Heritage says six unopened copies are known and none has sold publicly before.
- one of two known sealed copies of the original ASC Games US PC release of Grand Theft Auto, with development documents, offered as GTA VI reached stores on November 19
- a 1990 Nintendo World Championships gray cartridge; Heritage says fewer than 100 survive
- a sealed Chrono Trigger for Super Nintendo graded CGC 9.8 A++ (lot 28062)
- a sealed Ocarina of Time graded PSA 9.8 A++
- an archive of Kaz Aizawa's original box paintings for HAL America's NES and Game Boy games, including Joust and Adventures of Lolo
What sealed first-print Zeldas have sold for
| Date | Grade | Price | Venue |
|---|---|---|---|
| July 9, 2021 | Wata 9.0 A, early production | $870,000 | Heritage |
| August 24, 2024 | CGC 9.2 A | $375,000 | Heritage |
| May 24, 2025 | CGC 9.4 A+ | $300,000 | Heritage |
The copy in this sale is graded lower than all three, at 8.0. The 2025 CGC 9.4 A+ copy sold for less than the 2024 CGC 9.2 A did, a reminder that pedigree, timing and who is bidding matter as much as the number on the label.
Why it matters for the market
Graded games are having a big fall. Heritage and Goldin sold $1,133,354 of graded retro games in the 30 days to November 15, per What The Slab. This sale is the next real test of whether that demand holds at the top.
Collectors from cards are crossing over. Heritage says Japanese Pokémon games are drawing more interest as Pokémon card buyers move into video games, and the sale carries high-grade copies of Red, Crystal, LeafGreen and SoulSilver.
What it doesn't tell you. The $75,000 and $50,000 figures are live bids from before the session, not results. We'll report the final prices after the close.
This is market data and commentary, not investment advice.
Sources
- CollectiblesNews, First-Production Super Mario Bros. and Original Kaz Aizawa Nintendo Art Lead Heritage Video Games Auction, Nov 17, 2026
- CGC Video Games, Classic Nintendo Titles Certified by CGC Lead Ongoing Heritage Signature Auction, Nov 5, 2026
- CGC, CGC-Certified The Legend of Zelda Realizes a Record $375,000 in Heritage Sale, August 2024
- CGC Video Games, Record-breaking Zelda Realizes $300,000, May 28, 2025
- Antiques and the Arts Weekly, Heritage Resets Video Game Record Twice in One Sale, July 2021
- What The Slab, Retro Game Auction Market Report
- Heritage Auctions, Video Games Signature Auction #7455